Site menu:

Schilling Spews Only Hot Air As He Blasts La Russa

Bernie Miklasz
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
May 26, 2005

WHEN TONY LA RUSSA stopped by Boston all-sports station WEEI on May 16 to promote the book "3 Nights in August," little did he know that he'd ignite a controversy that would embroil himself, Edgar Renteria, Boston pitcher Curt Schilling and Red Sox fans.

When asked about Renteria's mediocre start in Boston, La Russa essentially repeated comments he made at the time Renteria turned down a four-year, $39 million offer to continue playing shortstop for the Cardinals to accept a four-year, $40 million deal with the Sox.

To paraphrase, La Russa said he feared that Renteria would have a difficult time with the baseball environment in Boston. Why? Because there would be more scrutiny and less forgiveness in contrast to the relative peace in St. Louis. Renteria, La Russa said, wouldn't be able to "hide" in Boston as he did in St. Louis.

In this spot on the baseball map, La Russa's comments were no big deal, because we've heard them before. It's been established that Renteria doesn't play well when stressed. We saw how Renteria, rattled by trade rumors, pressed in 2001, and Cardinals fans were less than patient with him at the time. But Renteria finally settled down and played to his usual standards after general manager Walt Jocketty issued a public no-trade guarantee.

Even though Boston fans and media members already were grumbling about Renteria's slow start, La Russa's comments retroactively gained currency last weekend, as Renteria struggled through a terrible series against Atlanta at Fenway Park. Renteria went one for 13, committed two errors and got booed after striking out with the bases loaded in the second inning of Sunday's game.

This apparently set off Schilling, who called WEEI twice this week and accused La Russa of setting Renteria up with the comments made during the May 16 interview.

"I just thought he put Edgar in a very bad situation, especially for a player he talks about and cares about so much. I thought he stuck him in a corner there," Schilling told WEEI.

Schilling's spin is confusing.

I didn't realize that La Russa controls the minds and emotions of Red Sox fans. I thought they could think for themselves, and boo for themselves, without prompting from outside influences. I believe Red Sox fans were smart enough to do the calculation: Renteria's .245 batting average, .297 on-base percentage and eight errors don't add up to a $10 million-a-year shortstop.

And in the interview with WEEI, Schilling ironically did what he faulted La Russa for doing by putting more onus on Renteria.

"He's struggling, no question," Schilling said. "Now all eyes are on him every at-bat, every pitch. Everybody has an answer, a solution. Unfortunately, none of those are going to work until Edgar gets over the hump himself."

Gee, Curt, when the team's star pitcher announces that Renteria is struggling and puts more focus on Renteria's labors, don't you think this will only increase the heat on Renteria? Schilling probably didn't realize he was actually validating La Russa's opinion about Renteria's comfort level in Boston.

In the follow-up interview with WEEI, Schilling took another shot at La Russa, characterizing La Russa as a "jilted lover" in the aftermath of Renteria 's defection. That remark prompted a popular Red Sox fan Web site to post a doctored photo of La Russa wearing a wedding dress.

"I don't know if Tony thought about what he was saying before he said it," Schilling told WEEI. "I would guess, knowing him, that ... looking back on what he said and how it's kind of played out that he's probably not real happy he did it."

Not exactly.

"It's amazing to me that there's anything objectionable in what I said," La Russa said Wednesday. "I have no idea what Schilling was hearing, reading, thinking, saying. I know this, Schilling is not helping Edgar. The more he talks about it, the more attention he brings to it, and Edgar doesn't want to be the center of attention. If he wants to help Edgar, he'll low-key it."

As for being a jilted lover .o.o.

"If you go back to the beginning of the offseason, I made public comments where, I had strong doubts whether Edgar could be part of our team because of economics," La Russa said. "I said our priority was pitching. I said that consistently. Here's our chunk of money, and we had to spend our money on pitching. And so, at risk were Edgar and Mike Matheny. I didn't expect that we could afford to sign them. I didn't think we could afford to sign Edgar, and we were making plans to play without him. And if we had signed Edgar, we couldn't have traded for (pitcher) Mark Mulder."

The Red Sox open a three-game series at Busch Stadium on June 6, and but it probably won't be the anticipated homecoming for Renteria.

"I'm done with St. Louis already, and I play with Boston right now. It's my house right now, my family," Renteria told reporters who cover the Red Sox.

There's more.

"I know the fans in Boston are the best in baseball," Renteria told reporters Tuesday in Toronto. "When you perform the way you're supposed to, they're behind you. When I play the way I'm supposed to play, the Boston fans will be behind me."

(Doesn't that make them front-runners?)

As for La Russa's comments, Renteria said, "I don't know why Tony would say that. I wanted to play in Boston. They offered me the best contract and I knew I wanted to come to Boston. I think the fans are great there. I knew what a great place to play Boston is and I haven't changed my mind about that. I'm going to show Tony that I can play here."

The Cardinals-Red Sox series just became a lot more intriguing.

Back to 2005 Articles Page